'A Southern farm is the beau ideal of Communism; it is a joint concern, in which the slave ... is far happier, because ... he is always sure of support.' ... 'The best governed countries, and which have prospered the most, have always been distinguished for the number and stringency of their laws,' ... 'liberty is an evil which government is intended to correct.'"
~Sociology for the South 1854 by George Fitzhugh-a socialist.
Mr. Fitzhugh argued that slaves were better off because they were free from decision making. His book asserts that Liberty only leaves people free to destroy themselves. The government must be the 'master' that keeps people safe (from themselves) and provides for them so they need not be burdened with working in an unfair and unjust world--they aren't suited for it.
If being free from choice is truly the ideal situation as Mr. Fitzhugh believed, then I can't imagine how oppressive it would be to have to make choices for everyone! I am left to marvel at the benevolence of those willing to be the government that is burdened with making the decisions for all of us. That, by Fitzhugh's argument, would be the most unfree, oppressive job ever. We should be grateful for those willing to do this for us. Those who seek to be our masters are making a great personal sacrifice. They truly are benevolent.
Of course this is the great idiocy of Fitzhughs premise. He criticizes the free market and capitalism for its harsh unfairness; it's corruption and greed (too much liberty, you see. This is what happens when you give us liberty). But he talks about government as if it is a God-like entity with selfless love and charity for all--government is above human folly--well, as long as the right people are running it--the elite class. (Would the elite class step aside and let God run the show? Not likely, God has proven himself to be too harsh and unfair. They are better than God. They are the only ones charitable enough to take on the burden of government and make it fair for all.)
(I just had a random thought about Barack Obama--where did that come from? That was wierd.)
If We the People are too incompetent to handle liberty are we competent enough to know what restraints our benevolent, all controling government should operate under? Certainly not. We will just have to leave that to them. It's a good thing we have 'them', the elite, above-human-folly, more-fair-than-God, superhumans among us that know all that stuff. What good fortune. And what a blessing for the rest of us--to be free from making choices--just like slavery.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment